Reviews for the 2004 Clos Mimi The Carlyle Hotel Paso Robles Syrah:

"Dark violet. Ripe cherry and bitter chocolate on the nose, with earthy licorice and espresso adding depth. Bitter cherry and blackcurrant flavors are firmed by youthful acidity, which lends brightness to the finish. Far less extreme than most of the wines I've had from this producer, showing vivid fruit and less wildness than I was expecting when I pulled the cork. (89 points)"

Josh Raynolds
International Wine Cellar
Issue 135
Nov/Dec 07

"Bottled exclusively for New York's luxury Carlyle Hotel, the 2004 Syrah The Carlyle Hotel has a dark ruby/purple color and a nice, sweet black currant and cherry nose with some smoke, earth, and spice. The wine is medium-bodied, not as complex as the Petite Rousse, but fruity, soft, and savory. Apparently it is only available at the Carlyle Hotel in New York, so my notes will say no more. (88 points)"

Robert M. Parker, Jr.
The Wine Advocate
Issue 172
28 August 2007